Title: Comparing Semantics of Logics for Multi-agent Systems.
Authors: Valentin Goranko, Department of Mathematics, Rand Afrikaans University;
   Wojciech Jamroga, Parlevink Group, University of Twente, and Institute of Mathematics, University of Gdansk

We draw parallels between several closely related logics that combine - in different proportions - elements of game theory, computation tree logics, and epistemic logics to reason about agents and their abilities. These are: the coalition game logics CL and ECL introduced by Pauly in 2000, the alternating-time temporal logic ATL developed by Alur, Henzinger and Kupferman between 1997 and 2002, and the alternating-time temporal epistemic logic ATEL by van der Hoek and Wooldridge (2002). In particular, we establish some subsumption and equivalence results for their semantics, as well as interpretation of the alternating-time temporal epistemic logic into ATL.

The focus in this paper is on models: alternating transition systems, multi-player game models (alias concurrent game structures) and coalition effectivity models turn out to be intimately related, while alternating epistemic transition systems share much of their philosophical and formal apparatus. Our approach is constructive: we present ways to transform between different types of models and languages.

Keywords: multi-agent systems, game theory, coalition logics, alternating-time temporal logic, epistemic logic.

Computational Intelligence Group @ Technical University of Clausthal Home
Human Media Interaction Group @ University of Twente
Computer Science Group @ University of Gdansk Last modified 2003-12-10